Give feedback people can use

A thoughtful response makes the next attempt easier.

Understand the goal

Read the brief and the creator’s question first. Consider their level of experience and constraints. Ask a question before assuming why they made a choice.

Be specific and kind

Point to one detail that works and one that could improve. Explain the effect, suggest a practical experiment, and separate personal taste from the task’s requirements.

Make room for a response

Advice is an invitation, not an instruction. Avoid public accusations of AI use based on style alone. Report evidence privately to moderation, and let the creator respond. Celebrate the next iteration, even when it takes a different direction than you expected.